Thrifting is something I have an intense (and possibly unhealthy) passion for. My mom used to take my sister and I to flea markets, antique stores, and thrift shops all the time in my hometown in Georgia which is where I developed my love for a good bargain, and the whole “one man’s trash” thing started to truly become my way of life. Since moving to New York, I’ve had to do a lot of searching by foot and online to find the best thrift stores the city has to offer. I thought I’d put together a list of my personal favorite places to look, so you can find yourself a gem the next time you’re here. I’ve also included my favorite stores in NYC, generally speaking, in case thrifting isn’t your scene – because NYC is home to some truly unique shops & businesses. I thought I’d take some of the guesswork out of exploration, and give you a handy syllabus of stops to make along your way.


Goodwill on 2nd Avenue between 87th and 88th

  • Super affordable
  • Good for vintage designer finds, and higher end brands (thanks to all of the rich folks who donate clothes in the Upper East Side)
  • Multiple locations around the city

Housing Works on 2nd Avenue and 90th

  • Awesome shop with reasonably priced designer and upscale clothes
  • Good place to find bags, shoes, and homewares
  • Good menswear selection
  • Multiple locations around the city

Flying Tiger on 2nd Avenue and 74th

  • Danish store dealing in affordable home goods, stationery, and trinkets.
  • Ikea’s kooky little sister.
  • Scandinavian & modern designs for a sleek, but quirky home & life.


Beacon’s Closet

  • Cool & affordable consignment shop
  • More mid-range brands, less designer finds
  • Multiple locations around the city


  • Super pricey urban menswear (I believe they have a Manhattan location as well.)
  • Cereal bar in the store
  • Sneakerheads will enjoy.


Opening Ceremony SoHo
Opening Ceremony SoHo via @openingceremony


  • Japanese store known for simple storage & home goods.
  • Stationery, home goods, and simple clothing.
  • They sell the best pens in the whole world.

Opening Ceremony

  • Showroom of urban, hip, designer ready to wear clothes & accessories.
  • Cool selection of shoes and shades.
  • Expensive but visually stimulating and worth a stroll.


Namaste Bookshp
Namaste Bookshop via @namastebookshop


  • Best bookstore in NYC.
  • Huge selection of books old & new.
  • Great place to get quirky gifts, stickers, and other baubles.

Ricky’s NYC

  • Best place to find unusual makeup in the city.
  • Great selection of online brands that are hard to find in stores: Morphe, Violet Voss, Sugarpill, BH Cosmetics, Ben Nye, Palladio, NYX, LA Girl, Dose of Colors.
  • They have FX makeup, skincare, haircare, and cosmetic makeup. I can’t get enough of this place. Locations all over the city as well.

Namaste Bookshop

  • Cool new-age bookshop with a variety of genres.
  • Crystals, incense, chimes, tarot cards and other spiritual objects.


Koryo Books
Koryo Books via @harpercollinsus

Koryo Books

  • Awesome Korean bookstore with Korean titles, K-pop merch, and stationery.


MUJI Chelsea
MUJI Chelsea via @mujiusa

Paper Presentation

  • The place to go in NYC if you’re into any sort of crafting at all.
  • Huge selection of paper goods & craft supplies.


  • Yes, another MUJI. Just letting you know there’s one in Chelsea, too.


  • Huge magic & costume shop, with tons of selection and cool trinkets.


  • An editorial-style shop whose entire space & theme change every 4-8 weeks.
  • They stock their shelves each season with new wares and items based around their new theme. They collaborate with artists and architects to completely reconstruct the space. It’s awesome.
  • Their themes can be super general: love, holidays, etc, or more specific, like their recent 90s Nickelodeon throwback.

Let me know if you guys would be interested in a food + drink guide as well – there is so much incredible food and coffee here.

Published by

Miranda Feneberger

Miranda Feneberger

In the middle of an existential crisis. If you have one of those super long phone chargers can you send it to me?